|
Post by billfeng on Aug 17, 2013 1:50:50 GMT
Culture often pits two opposite and equal forces against each other.
The famous Chinese philosophy of Yin and Yang dictates that these contrary forces are interconnected and interdependent in the natural world. During their meeting in the cave, the Dragon tells Grendel:
In my perspective, Grendel is like Joker as Humanity is like Batman. (Two entities of evil and good that will forever be pitted against one another) Without evil, there can be no progress for what is good. I see Grendel as being predestined to clash with humanity until his demise, but many of you see different. Is Grendel's fate intertwined with that of humanity as the Dragon mentioned in Chapter Five? Or, could it be possible that the Dragon is "shaping" the innate, monstrous nature within Grendel? Was Grendel's change a result of his own free will?
|
|
|
Post by kevinle on Aug 17, 2013 5:07:12 GMT
I think Grendel is definitely headed toward his demise due to conflicts with humans, but I do not think it can count as being predestined. He has perfect control over himself, as everyone else does. He has the intelligence and the capability to reroute his actions, but he chooses not to. This is not to say the dragon did not influence him. Grendel had the kindling for violence, and the dragon ignited it. The no-knife-shall-ever-cut-Grendel-again charm continued to fuel the fire. Grendel did reconsider his motives and actions multiple times, but he ultimately chose to continue wreaking havoc. So yes, the dragon shaped the monster, but Grendel's choices were rooted in free will. I don't think there is any predestination.
|
|
|
Post by carolinedorman on Aug 21, 2013 6:54:52 GMT
Although Grendel has the qualities and desires of a monster, he closely imitates the thoughts and feelings of man. Had he grown up with a couple of siblings or a mother who could intelligently communicate, I believe his role, as an enemy to the humans, would have been deeply altered. Perhaps it is fate that decided Grendel would grow up without any real companions. Thus, Grendel would seek meaning in pillaging the humans’ castle to escape his hollow isolation. I do not believe, however, that the dragon shaped the monstrous nature within Grendel. He only slightly encouraged it. If it is indeed fate that decides Grendel should exist without any companions, it is no great mystery that Grendel places himself in the humans’ world in order to belong somewhere. Even though Grendel’s place in the Dane’s world was antagonistic, he was at least significant to them. Grendel’s upbringing caused him to be closely intertwined with the humans, not the dragon’s words of wisdom.
|
|